A magician cuts his throat with impunity

Two men, sharing a wife, decide to test their supernatural powers by beheading each other. The first man survives decapitation unharmed, but when the second man attempts the same, he fails to restore himself and seeks help. The first man heals him, revealing their unequal abilities. This story highlights themes of hubris and the limits of one’s power.

Source: 
The Beaver Indians
by Pliny Earle Goddard
The American Museum of Natural History – Anthropological Papers
Volume X, Part 4
New York, 1912


► Themes of the story


Supernatural Beings: The protagonists possess supernatural abilities, allowing them to survive otherwise fatal injuries.

Trials and Tribulations: The men undergo a dangerous test to prove their powers, facing life-threatening challenges.

Cunning and Deception: The story involves elements of testing and outwitting death through supernatural means.

► From the same Region or People

Learn more about the Dane-zaa people


There was a man who had great supernatural power. The man with whom he shared a wife said to himself, “I, too, am just the same sort.” Thinking they would test their power they decided to cut off each other’s heads. The first man had his head cut off but he did not die. Then his companion cut his throat. He tried in vain to fix it again. He drew his hand across his throat twice but it made no difference. He was unable to restore himself. He went to his companion and said, “I thought I was the same kind as you but I am not.” Then his partner called him to him and put his hand on his throat. After that he got well. They lived all right. They were only testing themselves. At first before there were any white people, the Indians were powerful men. They secured their livings by means of supernatural power. That was when they used to wear leather.

► Continue reading…

Running and expanding this site requires resources: from maintaining our digital platform to sourcing and curating new content. With your help, we can grow our collection, improve accessibility, and bring these incredible narratives to an even wider audience. Your sponsorship enables us to keep the world’s stories alive and thriving. ♦ Visit our Support page

Leave a comment